I have been given a trick question to solve by my teacher today.

Question: How Many Combinations of 3 Fingers Chords Can you have in a Piano, if each key in a chord must have a minimum gap of two keys, and maximum gap of three keys? Assume there are total of 61 Keys in the Piano.

Now, to simplify i have broken down a 61 key piano into 5 scales. And also lets forget there are black and white keys, as they are irrelevant to our problem. 

Now how do i approach this? What formula should i form? Because, clearly there is a pattern here. I think if I can solve for one scale, i have to just multiply it by 5. 

Reference to Chords

More hints i Found - Each scale has only 12 Keys. We can assume 12 keys. And 4 chords can be formed from each key, except the last few keys of the piano.


in Word Problem Answers by

Your answer

Your name to display (optional):
Privacy: Your email address will only be used for sending these notifications.
Anti-spam verification:
To avoid this verification in future, please log in or register.

1 Answer

Given a starting key (the lowest note of the chord) there are only 4 types of chord with the following intervals between the notes of the chord: 2-2, 2-3, 3-2, 3-3. For the sake of illustration, let the bottom note of the chord be C. There are two ways of interpretating the meaning of gap. If a gap of 2 means two clear keys between two notes, then the minimum musical interval is a minor 3rd and a gap of 3 implies a major 3rd. The other interpretation is the distance between two adjacent notes of the chord, so 2 would mean a major 2nd and 3 a minor 3rd. So the chords with C as the lowest note would, under the first interpretation, be CE-F+ (C dim) where minus means flat and plus means sharp. The next chord is CE-G (C min), the next CEG (C maj), the last CEG+ (C aug). But there are 12 chromatic keys, so there will be 48 chords in one octave. The next group would be C# dim, C# min, C# maj, C# aug. The last key would be B dim, B min, B maj, B aug.

Under the second interpretation the chords would be CDE, CDF, CE-F, CE-F+.

The chords can be played in any octave and 61 keys make 5 octaves on a keyboard. So if we include the position of the chord as well as the type we need to multiply by 5 to give us 5×48=240 chords. But we are restricted by the highest note on the keyboard. Let’s suppose the keyboard starts on a C then it will also end on C. We need to subtract a few chords. In the highest octave we’re OK till we get to F as the lowest note. So  from C to E we have 20 chords. Then with F we have only F dim, F min, F maj; for F# we have only F# dim, so we have only 24 chords instead of 48, a loss of 24 chords. That makes the total 240-24=216. That’s under the first interpretation.

Under the second interpretation, we lose 16 chords in the highest octave because the last chords are GAB, GAC, GB-C, A-B-C. So there are 7×4+4=32 in the last octave. The total is 224.

by Top Rated User (716k points)

Related questions

2 answers
asked Oct 16, 2014 in Statistics Answers by anonymous | 125 views
1 answer
asked Mar 25, 2018 in Algebra 2 Answers by Paula | 70 views
Welcome to MathHomeworkAnswers.org, where students, teachers and math enthusiasts can ask and answer any math question. Get help and answers to any math problem including algebra, trigonometry, geometry, calculus, trigonometry, fractions, solving expression, simplifying expressions and more. Get answers to math questions. Help is always 100% free!
84,485 questions
89,386 answers
7,999 users