Solve the given  right spherical triangle with C= 90°

 

1.    B= 124° 15'     ,    b= 147°15'

 

2.      B= 130° 30'     ,    a= 14° 24'

 

by using NAPIERS RULE.

in Trigonometry Answers by

The question defines angle B twice, so there is an error in the question, assuming (1) and (2) are two properties of the same question.

If (1) and (2) are meant to be two separate questions, there is insufficient information in either of them to discover any other meaningful values.

Your answer

Your name to display (optional):
Privacy: Your email address will only be used for sending these notifications.
Anti-spam verification:
To avoid this verification in future, please log in or register.

1 Answer

Right spherical triangle C=90°. a, b, c are sides (measured as arc (subtended) angles of great circles) and triangle angles A, B , C as in plane triangles.

Note that in any triangle (spherical or plane) the shortest side is opposite the smallest angle. Also, the ratio of the sides in a triangle is the same as the ratio of the sines of their opposite angles (Sine Rule). These rules do not seem to be apparent in this question, but proof can be seen below in the application of Napier's Rule.

Napier’s Pentagon consists of 5 pentagon triangles p₁-p₅ inside a circle. The order of sides and angles (clockwise) is pentagon triangles containing b, A, c, B, a, cyclically reordered as  a, b, A, c, B, so that:

p₁=a, p₂=b, p₃=A, p₄=c, p₅=B. For p₃-p₅ complement the angles so we get: a, b, 90-A, 90-c, 90-B. Napier’s Pentagon helps to derive equations.

For a the adjacent pentagon triangles are b and 90-B and the opposite triangles are 90-A and 90-c. For b the adjacent triangles are a and A and the opposite triangles are B and c.

Napier’s Rules:

(1) sin(a)=cos(90-A)cos(90-c) (SIN-CO-OP); (2) sin(a)=tan(b)tan(90-B) (SIN-TA-AD);

(1) sin(b)=cos(90-c)cos(90-B); (2) sin(b)=tan(90-A)tan(a), etc. SIN-CO-OP and  SIN-TA-AD are the mnemonic representations; the relevant trig function can replace the trig function of complements (sin becomes cos and tan becomes cot).

In all, 10 equations can be derived by starting with any pentagon triangle. The sine of the “middle” triangle (which has two opposite and two adjacent triangles) can be derived from its adjacent (tangent product) and opposite (cosine product) pentagon triangles.

Unfortunately, in this question, B is defined as two different angles, and we don't have the size of angle A. So we have to assume that one of the given angles is A and the other B, but which is which? We need to explore the possibilities.

Here is Napier's Pentagon

Decimals are to 6 decimal place accuracy, and angles to the nearest minute.

(1) sin(a)=cos(90-A)cos(90-c)=sin(A)sin(c)=tan(b)tan(90-B)=tan(b)cot(B);

sin(a)=sin(14°24')=0.248690, cos(a)=0.968583 (because we are given a);

(2) sin(b)=cos(90-c)cos(90-B)=sin(c)sin(B)=tan(90-A)tan(a)=cot(A)tan(a);

sin(b)=sin(147°15')=0.540974, cos(b)=-0.841039 (because we are given b);

(3) sin(90-c)=cos(c)=cos(a)cos(b)=tan(90-A)tan(90-B)=cot(A)cot(B).

In (3) the ambiguity between A and B is irrelevant, because of the tangent product involving both angles.

sin(90-c)=cos(c)=tan(90-A)tan(90-B)=tan(-34°15')tan(-40°30')=0.581523,

c=cos-1(0.581523)=54°27'.

Since cos(c)=0.581523=cos(a)cos(b)=tan(90-A)tan(90-B)=cot(A)cot(B) and we know a and b we can confirm (or invalidate) (3).

cos(a)cos(b)=0.968583(-0.841039)=-0.814616.

So we have an inconsistency, because cos(c)=0.581523 but cos(a)cos(b)=-0.814616, and cos(c)≠sin(a)sin(b).

GIven this apparent inconsistency, it's not possible to proceed.

The Sine Rule (which applies to plane and spherical triangles) also fails to be true no matter which angle is A or B.

by Top Rated User (1.2m points)

Related questions

1 answer
asked May 17, 2021 in Trigonometry Answers by anonymous | 312 views
1 answer
asked Jul 10, 2013 in Trigonometry Answers by JR Level 1 User (820 points) | 3.7k views
1 answer
asked Jun 7, 2022 by Person | 568 views
1 answer
asked Dec 7, 2020 in Algebra 1 Answers by anonymous | 454 views
1 answer
asked Jun 28, 2020 in Algebra 1 Answers by Patrick | 455 views
1 answer
asked Aug 25, 2019 in Algebra 1 Answers by Hansolo | 364 views
1 answer
asked Aug 24, 2019 by Poop | 349 views
Welcome to MathHomeworkAnswers.org, where students, teachers and math enthusiasts can ask and answer any math question. Get help and answers to any math problem including algebra, trigonometry, geometry, calculus, trigonometry, fractions, solving expression, simplifying expressions and more. Get answers to math questions. Help is always 100% free!
87,516 questions
100,285 answers
2,420 comments
734,803 users