Do there exist any sets with a cardinality strictly between the cardinality of the set of natural numbers and the cardinality of the set of reals?
in Word Problem Answers by

Your answer

Your name to display (optional):
Privacy: Your email address will only be used for sending these notifications.
Anti-spam verification:
To avoid this verification in future, please log in or register.

2 Answers

Consider the set of two elements P₀={ a b } where a and b, b>a, are reals, that is, a,b∊ℝ.

We can assign the cardinals 1 and 2 to a and b respectively. That is, we can count the elements of P₀ and C(b)=n(P₀), where C denotes cardinality.

We can expand the set P by adding c where c=(a+b)/2, making P₁={ a c b } with cardinalities 1, 2 and 3. C(b)=n(P₁)=3. Then we create P₂={ a d c e b } where d=(a+c)/2 and e=(b+c)/2. C(b)=n(P₂)=5.

If we repeat the process we end up with C(b)=n(Pᵪ)=2ᵡ+1. For example, if X=10, C(b)=n(P₁₀)=1025.

There are an infinite number of reals, as X→∞, and there will be a corresponding infinite number of cardinals.

Between a and b there will be an infinite number of reals (e.g., a=-1, b=1, c=0, d=-0.5, e=0.5, f=-0.75, g=-0.25, h=0.25, i=0.75, etc.).

There are an infinite number of natural numbers, but the set of reals includes the set of natural numbers, making the set of natural numbers a subset of the reals. The “infinities” of the natural numbers and the reals are not the same. Also, there is no first element a (-∞) or last element b (∞), so it would not be possible to assign cardinality to the elements in an infinite set. I think cardinality can only be applied to a finite subset of reals and a corresponding finite set of cardinal natural numbers.

Another argument is that the natural numbers are strictly positive, but the range of reals extends from -∞ to +∞, so that even if the set of cardinals were to be sufficient to count the reals from 1 to ∞ we would need the same set again to count the reals from -∞ to 0. Therefore there can be no set of cardinals mapping to the reals.

 

by Top Rated User (1.2m points)
achhi bat hai yaar galat ka question hai yaar
by

Related questions

1 answer
asked Feb 2, 2015 in Word Problem Answers by Rod Top Rated User (1.2m points) | 1.0k views
1 answer
asked Sep 10, 2014 in Other Math Topics by anonymous | 872 views
0 answers
asked Jun 11, 2013 in Pre-Algebra Answers by anonymous | 652 views
1 answer
asked Mar 20, 2021 in Other Math Topics by algebrakid69 Level 1 User (120 points) | 480 views
1 answer
asked Jun 8, 2020 in Other Math Topics by ainm Level 1 User (220 points) | 554 views
1 answer
asked Jun 8, 2020 in Other Math Topics by ainm Level 1 User (220 points) | 541 views
1 answer
asked Sep 3, 2017 in Algebra 1 Answers by anonymous | 448 views
1 answer
asked Jan 29, 2015 in Statistics Answers by VLanham Level 1 User (420 points) | 2.0k views
1 answer
asked Jun 2, 2014 in Other Math Topics by jayalakshmi Level 1 User (240 points) | 1.0k views
1 answer
asked Jun 2, 2014 in Other Math Topics by jayalakshmi Level 1 User (240 points) | 696 views
Welcome to MathHomeworkAnswers.org, where students, teachers and math enthusiasts can ask and answer any math question. Get help and answers to any math problem including algebra, trigonometry, geometry, calculus, trigonometry, fractions, solving expression, simplifying expressions and more. Get answers to math questions. Help is always 100% free!
87,516 questions
100,285 answers
2,420 comments
735,140 users